What to do with old furniture in Chicago

The short answer

Four options, in the order most people should try them: sell it, give it away, donate it, or have it hauled. The first three are free and slow. The fourth costs a published number and happens on a date you pick.

The prices for the fourth: a sofa is $126, a dresser is $126, a six-to-eight-seat dining table is $163, a queen mattress is $103. A one-bedroom's worth of furniture is usually a quarter truck at $241. The minimum for any visit is $75.

The Chicago-specific complication is timing. If your furniture problem exists because of a May 1 or October 1 lease flip, you do not have the runway that selling and donating need. Decide early which track you are on.

Selling: what actually moves in this city

Chicago has a deep secondhand market and it is very specific about what it wants.

Moves fast: mid-century anything, solid wood dressers and sideboards, vintage dining sets, bar stools, decent desks, and bookcases that are actually wood. Moves slowly or not at all: sectionals, sleeper sofas, particleboard in any form, and anything with a stain on it.

The practical obstacle here is not the listing, it is the stairs. A buyer who agrees to a price for a dresser in a third-floor Lakeview walk-up frequently reconsiders when they see the back staircase, and half of them arrive without a second person. If you are selling anything heavy out of a three-flat, say in the listing which floor it is on and whether there is alley access. You will get fewer messages and more actual buyers.

Giving it away and the alley economy

Chicago alleys run a real informal exchange. A decent dresser left by a garage in Logan Square on a Saturday afternoon is often gone before dinner, and everyone on the block knows it.

Use it honestly and it works. The rules that keep it working: only your own alley, only things a person would actually want, only when the weather will not wreck them, and only if you are willing to bring it back inside the next morning if nobody took it. Post it somewhere with the cross streets so people know it is there.

Where it fails is upholstery and mattresses. A sofa left out in Chicago gets rained on within a day and frozen into the gravel by December, and at that point it is not a gift, it is a pile behind somebody's garage that the building owner is going to get a notice about. Mattresses fail hardest of all, for bed bug reasons that every bulky-item program in the country spells out.

Donating: good option, real standards

Resale and reuse organizations across the metro take furniture, and the good ones will collect. What they will not take is not arbitrary: they need it structurally sound, clean, free of smoke and pet damage, and with no sign of pests in the upholstery. Many take no mattresses at all. Most will not take flat-pack that has been assembled and moved twice, because it does not survive a third trip.

Two practical notes for Chicago. First, pickup scheduling for donation collection runs weeks out, and it runs hardest in late April and late September, which is exactly when everyone in this city needs it. Book early or do not count on it. Second, most donation crews will not carry down three flights of a back staircase, which rules out a large share of the city's housing stock.

If you have runway and a ground-floor unit, donate. If you have two weeks and a third floor, do not build the plan around it.

Hauling: the version that has a date on it

Disposal and the carry-out are inside every one of those. There is no stair charge, no walk-up fee, and no difference between a garden unit in Bridgeport and a third floor in Andersonville.

Which track to choose, by situation

You are moving on May 1 or October 1. Haul. Selling and donating both need weeks, and the two weeks around those dates are when the entire city is competing for the same pickup slots. Book the removal for the day before the move, not the day of.

You are redecorating and nothing is urgent. Sell the good pieces, offer the middling ones, donate what is left, and haul the remainder in one stop. That last stop is usually smaller and cheaper than people expect.

You are clearing a parent's place in Jefferson Park or Beverly. Mixed. There is usually real value in the dining set and the sideboard, real donation potential in the linens and kitchen, and a truck's worth of everything else. A full truck is $732.

It is January and you have a sofa in the living room you hate. Haul. Nobody is coming to carry it down an icy back staircase for free in February.

Three-flats, walk-ups and the back staircase

Any plan for Chicago furniture has to survive the back stairs, because that is how almost everything leaves. Rear wooden porches, steep runs, short landings, and a turn at the top where a queen box spring stops being possible.

Things worth knowing before you make a plan. A sectional comes apart and a one-piece sofa does not. A solid wood dresser goes down easier with the drawers out and stacked separately. A flat-pack wardrobe will not survive disassembly, so do not promise it to anyone. And a sleeper sofa weighs what a sleeper sofa weighs, which is why it is the single most common item people give up on selling and just send out.

None of that affects what you pay us. It affects what you can realistically promise a stranger on the internet.

Two worked examples

Wicker Park one-bedroom, October 1. Sofa at $126, queen mattress and box spring set at $143, standard dresser at $126: $126 + $143 + $126 = $395. One stop the day before the movers come.

Portage Park bungalow, downsizing, keeping the good stuff. Dining table at $163, four dining chairs at $45 each, and a solid wood bookcase at $123: $163 + $45 + $45 + $45 + $45 + $123 = $466.

If the list gets longer than that, the truck-fill steps take over: $241 for a quarter, $431 for a half, $732 for a full load.

Frequently asked questions